Sharechat Logo

Forum Archive Index - January 2004

Please note usage of the Forum is subject to the Terms & Conditions.

 
Messages by Date [ Next by Date Previous by Date ]
Messages by Thread [ Next by Thread Previous by Thread ]
Post to the Forum [ New message Reply to this message ]
Printable version
 

Fw: [sharechat] Warehouse Xmas Advertising


From: John H T Wilkinson <jhtw@clear.net.nz>
Date: Wed, 28 Jan 2004 19:28:32 +1300


Title: Message
Well Karyn W here is the answer to your earlier comments.
Are you getting the mailers ?
 
JHTW
 
-- Original Message -----
Sent: Wednesday, January 28, 2004 7:03 PM
Subject: RE: [sharechat] Warehouse Xmas Advertising

Dear John, thank you for your enquiry regarding advertising.  In answer the the specific questions
 
The TV commercials are designed for brand awareness and specials that drive foot traffic.
This is supported by weekly mailers that have full details of the address and location of the stores.
It is not standard for TV to highlight locations.
 
All advertising is developed and media purchased through Australian companies and not NZ companies.
 
regards
Mark Fennell
 
 
 
-----Original Message-----
From: John H T Wilkinson [mailto:jhtw@clear.net.nz]
Sent: Monday, 22 December 2003 3:00
To: Mark Fennell
Subject: Fw: [sharechat] Warehouse Xmas Advertising

Hello,
 
As a Warehouse Shareholder it it disturbing to read the following comments from an ex New Zealand customer now on the spot in Australia.
I would be interested to hear The Warehouse's opinion of Karyn's comments.
 
Regards,
John Wilkinson
Wellington
New Zealand
 
----- Original Message -----
From: Karyn W
Sent: Monday, December 22, 2003 12:11 PM
Subject: [sharechat] Warehouse Xmas Advertising

The Warehouse are running a Xmas ad campaign - but again, they have failed
to tell anyone where their stores are!
It is customary amongst the big chains like Harvey Norman, Sleepyhead, DFO,
or any other large outlet that has its stores in the suburbs, to list the
surburbs and/or street addresses of its stores in the area when they run a
TV ad campaign.
  Some chains even provide street maps, especially if they
have just opened a new store, so that people know how to get there.
This means that all the big chains do regional advertising - ie. Melbourne
will get an ad listing all the Melbourne stores, Sydney will get one listing
Sydney suburban stores.
I suspect the Warehouse is trying to run a cheap national ad campaign rather
than regional in order to save money, but really it is pretty pointless
paying for any ad campaign that fails to get people in the doors.  Unless
you know if there is a store near to you or not, you are not going to bother
to go out looking for it.
Another fundamental mistake in understanding the Australian market - they
cant even get the advertising right.  I wonder if they are using a NZ
advertising company rather than an Australian one, and the lack of local
knowledge in advertising customs means the Warehouse is continuing to
misread the market and the way retail is undertaken over here.
Karyn


----- Original Message -----
From: Karyn W
Sent: Friday, December 12, 2003 7:54 PM
Subject: [sharechat] [Re] Tindall got it right in Oz

Brian Gaynor got it right.  The Warehouse should have taken some time to
work out whether or not their approach of standalone shops would work in
Australia as well as it has in NZ.  If they had, they would have realised
very quickly that its NOT a successful formula at all.  Just like Pizza Hut
- they've bought an underperforming business, thought they could turn it
around, but have failed to realise that consumers in Australia just dont
behave like consumers in NZ.

In Australia people dont want to drive miles just to go to one shop.  There
is no spare real estate in the inner city areas (and if there were there
would be an apartment building being built on it!) so big barn like retail
outlets are relegated to the outer suburbs.  It takes about an hour to drive
from the city out to those suburbs.  So who would want to drive that far
just to save a few bucks on hair shampoo or plastic containers?  This is the
first major difference between NZ and Australia - driving distances and time
dictate where you shop.

Aussies love to shop at the gigantic malls, which contain everything that
you could possibly need, are located close enough to their home and the
major freeways to be able to get to in under 20 minutes.   Chadstone in
Melbourne is over 90,000 sq metres of retail space (with another 40,000 sq m
proposed), Westfield Parramatta is 113,000 sq metres in size.  All of these
malls contain four or five "discount" chain stores that sell the same stuff
as the Warehouse does, enough to allow you to shop around for the best
price.  Why go anywhere else?

In addition, Coles Myer is hell bent on regaining a healthy share price, and
have heavily invested in re-establishing KMart and Target over here as the
discount stores of choice.  Both these stores are located in the big malls,
and spend a fortune on advertising (think McDonalds!).

But the real nail in the coffin is the presence of small bargain stores on
the main streets of each and every suburb.  What NZ does not have, but what
Australia specialises in, is the small locally owned and operated, sole
proprieter shops.  Each suburb has a main shopping strip, full of small
stores.  My suburban street strip contains 5 of these little "$2 type"
stores, and if I need anything I walk down the road and buy it locally. 
They are run mostly by Asian immigrants, and everything is imported from
Asia and is dead cheap.  If 5 little "Warehouse" type stores can do enough
trade on one street in one suburb to stay in business, is it any wonder that
a large store miles out of town is not doing any?

Importers also work on a huge scale.  Usually every weekend the local or
city town hall or exhibition centre is having an "importers clearance sale"
of books, toys, DVDs, CDs, manchester, rugs, etc.  And for even more choice,
there are the multitude of "Markets" - where you can also buy pretty much
everything you are looking for as well as pick up your fresh meat and
produce.

But for a personal anecdote - I have been here for 2.5 years.  I have seen
Warehouse ads on TV only twice.  I have never seen a Warehouse store in
Melbourne, and I do not have a clue where any of them are located (they dont
even tell you in the ads!).  And I am alert to the brand!  Is the Average
Aussie shopper really going to go out of their way to track down a store
that they have never heard of, and drive miles to get there, when what they
want can be bought just down the road or the next time they are
clothes/supermarket/book shopping in the mall or market?

I loved the Warehouse when I lived in NZ.  It was always first choice when I
needed to buy something that it sold.  However, here in Australia I have no
desire or need to visit that type of store, and certainly would not make a
special effort to drive to it.  I shop locally first, then the discount
stores and Kmart in Chadstone Mall, then Sth Melbourne market (in that
order).


On the other hand, I have seen Glassons and Michael Hill stores over here. 
As has every other Australian who's ever been in to a shopping mall.  Guess
that explains their sales success :-)  I am now watching TNZ with interest
here ...

Karyn

 
Messages by Date [ Next by Date: Re: [sharechat] Trading and life Cristine Kerr
Previous by Date: RE: [sharechat] DPC HQP again and again by macdunk Malcolm Cameron ]
Messages by Thread [ Next by Thread: Re: Fw: [sharechat] Warehouse Xmas Advertising Karyn W
Previous by Thread: Re: Re: [sharechat] Viruses G Stolwyk ]
Post to the Forum [ New message Reply to this message ]

IRG See IRG research reports