Sharechat Logo

Law lords criticise Apple Fields for 'contrived' appeal

By Chris Hutching

Friday 11th July 2003

Text too small?
Apple Fields received a drubbing from the Privy Council in a ruling that questioned what reasonable complaint the company could make about the transaction being appealed.

Major shareholder Tom Kain went to London two weeks ago with the appeal.

"The complaint is indeed highly contrived," according to the report by Lord Scott of Foscote. He was supported by Lord Rodger of Earlsferry, Lord Hobhouse of Woodborough, Lord Slynn of Hadlee and Lord Hutton.

Apple Fields was complaining about the sale of land it owned at Styx (now the Northwood subdivision) north of Christchurch by mortgagee Damesh Holdings, associated with businessman Ken Smith.

The Privy Council said the complaint was "staggering" in light of the benefits it gleaned Apple Fields and because the transaction was largely structured by then chairman and legal representative, Geoffrey Cone, who has since resigned (from the company.)

The essence of the complaint was that Mr Smith was associated with the mortgagee Damesh and with the purchaser of the land, Styx Developments, and therefore had a duty of care to obtain the best price but had failed to do so.

The claim offends both equity and common sense, according to the law lords. The benefit to Apple Fields was that $21 million was written off its debts because ANZ was prepared to write off a portion of what it was owed to help settle the deal, even though the land was worth about $13.4 million.

The $13.4 million figure was accepted in an earlier High Court judgment by Justice John Hansen after witnesses gave evidence of valuations ranging from $10 million to $25 million.

"There is no issue in the present case of [lack of] good faith [by Mr Smith]."

  General Finance Advertising    

Comments from our readers

No comments yet

Add your comment:
Your name:
Your email:
Not displayed to the public
Comments to Sharechat go through an approval process. Comments which are defamatory, abusive or in some way deemed inappropriate will not be approved. It is allowable to use some form of non-de-plume for your name, however we recommend real email addresses are used. Comments from free email addresses such as Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, etc may not be approved.

Related News:

Serko brings in in $45m capital raising
Fonterra farmers urge MPs to unshackle cooperative
NZ dollar benefits as EU likely to grant Brexit extension
24th October 2019 Morning Report
OPINION: All the questions the convention centre fire asks
MARKET CLOSE: NZ stocks drop as investors dump power companies on smelter scare
NZ dollar eases after another Brexit failure
SkyCity, Fletcher won't name their insurers
NZ stocks smacked by smelter review, SkyCity fire
No govt cash for Tiwai Point - Woods

IRG See IRG research reports