Sharechat Logo

Anderton's bank float costs challenged

Friday 17th August 2001

Text too small?
By Jock Anderson

A securities expert says Deputy Prime Minister Jim Anderton's cost estimate of $4-7 million for a dumped People's Bank $40 million share issue is "extraordinarily high."

Mr Anderton's figures bear no relation to other similar offers, the estimated costs of which come in well below his figures.

After the Alliance leader's major faux pas of promoting the bank as a safe investment, the taxpayer is lumbered with the full establishment costs of $80 million instead of $40 million for a public/private partnership favoured by government advisers (NBR, August 3 and 10).

Mr Anderton is under investigation by the Securities Commission and his prosecution is sought after a complaint he breached securities law when promoting the bank.

He gave the high cost of a public float as one of the reasons the government decided to totally fund the bank and not proceed with a public/private partnership.

Comparing Mr Anderton's $4-7 million estimated cost for a $40 million issue with other similar offers, Chapman Tripp securities expert Tim Williams said Mr Anderton's figures seemed "extra-
ordinarily high."

Mr Williams said the $4-7 million estimate was well above the costs of most of the major New Zealand offerings Chapman Tripp had acted on in the last five years.

He said the recent Mission Contact Finance redeemable preference share offer for $150 million was a suitable comparison.

"It had estimated expenses of $2.6 million and it was more than six times the size of the proposed People's Bank offer," Mr Williams said.

Drawing total estimated costs from the relevant prospectus Mr Williams illustrated the estimated expenses on other similar offers with the table above.

Asked where he got his $4-7 million figure, Mr Anderton said it came from his official and professional staff.

Meanwhile, a government witch hunt had not found a source for highly embarrassing uncensored official documents obtained by Act New Zealand finance spokesman Rodney Hide concerning the bank and New Zealand Post, some of which are now on the Act website at <http://www.act.org.nz/kiwibank>.

Mr Hide said Treasury reports showed the government to be irresponsible in providing $80 million to New Zealand Post for the bank and showed NZ Post's board to be irresponsible in proceeding with the bank in the face of its own independent advisers recommending against it.

"Treasury officials advised that they considered the People's Bank to be of negative value, to pose considerable fiscal risks and the public policy benefits to be insignificant," said Mr Hide, who intends to continue releasing more secret papers.

ESTIMATED EXPENSES ON SIMILAR OFFERS
DateNameSize
($m)
Est costs
($m)

June 01Mission Contact Finance (rps)1502.6
Aug 00Genesis R&D Corp34.52.84
July 00Edison Contact Finance (rps)2404.8
May 00eVentures NZ301.4
June 99Ryman Healthcare272
June 99Colonial First State Prop 1454.9
May 97Infratil International49.92.2


  General Finance Advertising    

Comments from our readers

No comments yet

Add your comment:
Your name:
Your email:
Not displayed to the public
Comment:
Comments to Sharechat go through an approval process. Comments which are defamatory, abusive or in some way deemed inappropriate will not be approved. It is allowable to use some form of non-de-plume for your name, however we recommend real email addresses are used. Comments from free email addresses such as Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, etc may not be approved.

Related News:

SML - Synlait Milk Limited - Trading Halt of Securities
AIA - Auckland Airport announces board chair changes
AIA - Auckland Airport announces board chair changes
CEN - Tauhara commissioning progress update
FPH initiates voluntary limited recall
March 28th Morning Report
KFL Celebrates 20 Years of Excellence in Investment Mgmt.
SVR - Savor FY24 Earnings Guidance & Change in Banking Partner
NZK - NZ King Salmon Investments Limited FY24 Results
March 27th Morning Report