Sharechat Logo

Daily ShareChat: GPG

By Jenny Ruth

Tuesday 6th July 2010

Text too small?
 Jenny Ruth

 

Sacked Guinness Peat Group director Tony Gibbs' alternative restructuring plan was simply to do what chairman Sir Ron Brierley has been promising for two years, says ASB Securities analyst Florian Burch.

The GPG board said Gibbs' proposal "fails to take account of the complexities inherent in GPG's current structure," including the various stages of maturity of its investments and the condition of its biggest investment Coats, and contradicts external advice.

"If those elements do indeed prevent a tangible return of value to shareholders, what was the chairman doing promising such a return of value for the last two years?" Burch asks.

"Going by the shape of the board's initial proposal and by the reasons it gave for dismissing Mr Gibbs' proposal, it now appears the chairman's promises bore little chance of being kept in a foreseeable timeframe," he says.

The company has made little effort in the last two years to keep the chairman's promise or to manage its investments to a point of maturity, Burch says. "Why has it recently increased investments in Australia (eg in MMC Contrarian, Tandou and PrimeAg) that now seem to be being held up among the reasons not to return cash as promised?"

Gibbs has at least achieved partial success with the board deciding to appoint three independent directors to lead the restructuring, Burch says.

 

Investment rating: outperform (but with high risk attached due to the uncertainty around the shape of any restructuring).

 



  General Finance Advertising    

Comments from our readers

No comments yet

Add your comment:
Your name:
Your email:
Not displayed to the public
Comment:
Comments to Sharechat go through an approval process. Comments which are defamatory, abusive or in some way deemed inappropriate will not be approved. It is allowable to use some form of non-de-plume for your name, however we recommend real email addresses are used. Comments from free email addresses such as Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, etc may not be approved.

Related News:

GPG still wrangling UK pension liability, Coats 1H earnings more than doubles
Guinness Peat completes $1.4 billion in asset sales, turns focus to Coats
Guinness Peat exits last asset outside Coats, sells Tower stake for $118 mln
GPG focuses on cost cutting as restructuring plan is delayed by UK pensions regulator
GPG names new non-executive chairman of Coats
GPG says UK regulator extends investigation into its pension schemes
GPG pension headache puts brake on wind-down plan
GPG sells stake in ASX-listed Ridley Corp for A$54 mln in cash
GPG to reap 92 mln pounds from latest round of asset sales
GPG thrown curved ball as UK regulator looks at Coats pension plan